We, as a couple of humans that require food to live, tend to be fairly aggressive about getting into any restaurant that others have deemed "impossible" to get a reservation at. Thanks to the tenacity of Eric calling as often as he possibly could, we got a 6:30pm reservation for 4 on a Saturday at Lucia. The look they gave us when we entered said "please stop calling us at 7am, enjoy your meal, we hope you live in another state." Or maybe it just said "you guys seem confident in your height difference." Either way, we were seated immediately with our good friends George and Angela, who had also heard that Lucia was THE ONLY place to eat a decent meal in Dallas anymore.
Our waiter looked like a younger, distant cousin of Lou Diamond Phillips, and Angela and I proceeded to shout LOU! LOU! whenever we wanted more bread (which was every two seconds) at him. This may account for why he wasn't necessarily the friendliest waiter we'd ever met. He also made it very clear that at Lucia they a. do not split checks b. do not give you more than a little bit of the delicious bread c. if you ask for more bread, they pretend to forget and d. you CANNOT order one course at a time, you order all at once for the whole table. I tried to make conversation with Lou by asking him if he was from England because I am so perceptive and can always detect a hint of an accent. He was from Oak Cliff. Don't talk to your waiter and play around with them unless you're at TGI Friday's or a place where they write their name upside down in crayon on your table. This is our wisdom, given freely to you. That being said, this was by far one of the best meals we've ever had in Dallas, and it ranks in the top ten best meals of our lives. Here's what we had:
Cheese board- Gabietou, Smokey Blue, O'Banon, OCooch Mountain, nuts and preserves
We loved the variety and the amounts of the cheeses. George mentioned that there was a flavor in the fruit preserves and nuts that reminded him of something Cuban he ate years and years ago, and it's always fun to watch someone be transported back in time to a different place by food. To break down the cheeses for you:
gabietou: a sheep's milk and cow's milk combination cheese that is semi-soft. The rind on this cheese smells exactly like cigar smoke. It was almost an overwhelming smell, but once we tasted it, the smell made sense. If you like smokey and sour cheeses, you'll enjoy this one.
smokey blue: the bleu is always the most recognizable on any cheese plate and fairly self explanatory. We tend to prefer a spicier blue cheese, so the mild smokiness of this one wasn't our particular favorite. George and Angela loved it, though, and they are a little less into spicy foods than we are, so it's still recommended!
O'Banon: this is a mild goat cheese. There are two types of O'Banon out there; American O'Banon is slightly milder and softer than the French O'Banon. This cheese was my particular favorite because it had the tartness of goat cheese with a firmer texture.
OCooch Mountain: a mountain-style, raw milk cheese that is so nutty and firm with a little crunch. Hard cheeses are always a go-to in our house, so this one hit the spot!
Salumi misti- a tasting of house made cured meats (black pepper salame, fennel orange salame,coppa, culatello, coppa di testa, chicken liver crostini, and lardo crostini)
All of the salumi misti plate is worth trying! We couldn't get enough of the chicken liver crostini, which was so perfectly salted and toasted with that creamy, rich chicken liver on it. I did not eat the lardo crostini. As Angela and I both said, we will never be big enough foodies to eat fat on a piece of toasted bread. Our husbands didn't have much to say in favor of the animal fat toast either. My favorite was the black pepper salame, and it was nice to try the coppa di testa raw before eating it later in a bite of pasta that George and Angela ordered.
Spring pea agnolotti dal plin with tendrils and tesa
I gobbled these amazing little packets of peas and ricotta like they were little bits of ambrosia. Such an unassuming presentation, and yet the flavors were married together so perfectly that every ingredient complemented the others seamlessly. The peas were crisp and pop in your mouth when you bite down. There's no mushy, mealy texture here! This dish is the epitome of springtime and the pasta is perfectly chewy and fresh. Order it. Do not hesitate.
Swiss chard and testa casonceilli with green garlic broth
George and Angela had this dish, but we're still reviewing it because the one bite each of us had was INCREDIBLE. The green garlic broth is a revelation- bright and refreshing and not at all spicy or too strong. The pasta was, as the other dish showed, perfectly fresh and chewy. The testa casoncelli is just packed to the gills inside the pasta and was so moist and salty. We loved it!
Alaskan halibut with sunchokes, Calabrian chili, and Castelvetrano olive
Also a George and Angela dish...we understand if you'd rather eat with them than eat with us now, as they clearly ordered some delicious meals. This halibut was some of the best cooked fish I've had at a restaurant in a very, very long time. Being from Hawaii, and with Eric having been to Hawaii twice now to sample all the so-fresh-it-just-jumped-on-the-plate fish available, our standards are set very high when it comes to ordering fish in a non-coastal city. This halibut was perfect and the dressing on the salad and sides were just the right balance of heartiness and acidity for the meal.I actually think they changed the menu to have fingerling potatoes and these mixed greens rather than haivng sunchokes and Calabrian chili. Regardless, it was a fresh fish entree done right.
Veal chop with asparagus and fresh morel mushrooms
This was Eric's main dish. I wrote down the things he said about it. Please excuse the disjointed words as this was recorded between bites:
"Mmm. Oh wow. Cooked to perfection. Wow. Seasoned well. Very tender. You don't get this kind of thickness anywhere else! You can taste the flavor.Aromatic. This rub is great. Grilled right. Crunchy on the outside. Middle is medium rare. The fat brings out the flavors of whatever it was rubbed with. Dang. Wow."
For dessert, we ordered all four available. And there are no pictures because we dug in before we had a chance to photograph anything.
Carnaroli rice pudding with dried peach compote, caramel, and almonds
This was Eric's number one pick for best dessert. The texture was different from traditional rice pudding in that it's almost a light, yogurt-like texture. The caramel on top with nuts added a wonderful sweetness and depth of flavor. George, Angela, and I personally felt that this dish was missing some sort of zing. Maybe grapefruit or orange zest? It needed a little more flavor.
Bombolini with hazelnut, chocolate, and orange
There were four tiny little donut holes that didn't really tickle my fancy. I am personally not a fan of any citrus mixed with chocolate, so I didn't expect to be blown away by this dessert. George liked it very much, as did Angela. What's funny is that out of the four desserts, each one SHOULD have been a home run for each of us, given our own specific tastes (Angela loves any sort of citrus, Eric is a lifelong fan of rice pudding, George loves chocolate, and I am the gelato queen) but they all fell short.
Caffe corretto gelato with cardamom ladyfingers and lemon cream
Cardamom is such a unique and wonderful flavor to use when baking, so I was really anticipating the cardamom ladyfingers; however, there was no distinct cardamom that came out in each bite, it just tasted like a butter cookie. The word "ladyfinger" calls to mind light, fluffy, slightly sweet pastries, but these were the texture of hard cookies and crumbled very easily. The gelato was coffee gelato- nothing great, nothing terrible about it, but very forgettable. This dish could've easily been elevated with more cardamom, a ladyfinger-like texture, and perhaps a crumbling of caramelized hazelnuts on top of the gelato rather than the almost non-existent topping of lemon cream.
Meyer lemon panna cotta with caramelized grapefruit and lemon verbena
This was MY personal favorite. It tasted like a delicious, creamy greek yogurt. I liked it the best because it was better than the other dishes, but again, the bar was set fairly low. As you're probably beginning to realize, we weren't overly impressed with any of the desserts. It's something Lucia should really consider working on. Dessert is the best way to end a meal on a high note, and a chance to take a meal from great to unforgettable. This was a missed opportunity.
Overall, we loved our meal at Lucia! I hate to be so hard on them for the deserts, but each one truly missed the mark and the bar had been set so high from dinner that we were expecting a much more awe-inspiring final course. Thanks for the meal, Lucia, and we'll be back...when we can get a reservation!